Wednesday, February 17, 2010



Shame on you Jayaram!

The news is that Actor Jayaram made a nasty comment on his domestic help; specifically on her looks. He reportedly told a Malayalam TV channel, recently, that "my maid, a Tamil woman, is like a dark fat buffalo. So how can I look at her", when asked whether he had taken a second look at his housemaid in real life. The interview was in the context of his recent film. Of course, his comments put him up in a soup and there were protests against Jayaram’s comments in Tamil Nadu and a Tamil outfit went to the extent of ransacking the garden in his house in Chennai.

There are two or three points that I would like to make in this note. Firstly, I strongly feel that we must learn to treat any attack on the modesty of a woman (what Jayaram did in this case) as an assault on women irrespective of the colour, caste, religion, place, groups and so on. How does it matter whether the victim is a Tamil woman or a woman from Rajastan or Bihar? Hence the outcry “Tamil Woman” is unwarranted. It is yet another matter that the majority of Tamil Films too depict/treat women as a commodity rather than human beings.

Now about Tamil women! As a person who has been working with women for many years, I have had ample opportunities to travel all over India to work with the less privileged working women. The Tamil women, especially those from the lowest economic strata, had always surprised me with their endurance and fortitude. They are very enterprising and hard working and they take up any job without any inhibition.

In Tamil Nadu, there are many women headed families or families in which women are the main bread winner. They work in the agricultural field, run small eateries on the road side, work as flower vendors in front of temples, theatres, beaches and any other crowd pulling places and also a large number of them work as domestic workers; sometimes they manage to work in more than 6 houses and the with the meagre income they contribute largely to their households. So describing a human being, who also happens to be cleaning up your mess at home, by her colour and figure is a criminal and inhuman act. Hence Jayaram’s words, no doubt, are condemnable.

At a different level, I am not surprised by his comment, in the sense that, there is no dearth of Jayarams in Kerala, the most literate state in India. If you sit through any of the “comedy’’ shows in the Malayalam channels, the major event would be caricaturing politicians and second to that is vulgarising women through suggestive comments. In most of the cases women are being treated like commodities and there is no sense of shame in visualising them in such a way in the TV serials.

In real life too, women are intimidated in the public places and public transport. I still remember that in my college days; in the private buses, there is a “creature” called ‘kili’, who is supposed to be the cleaner of the bus. He would invariably stand on the steps of the bus and that used to be very inconvenient for the women passengers to get down from the bus. Sometimes, these kilis would rub their shoulder against the girls. As student activists, we used to protest against this and would insist that this man should get down while we got off the bus. And invariably, these men used to make rude comments insulting our looks. Their comment would be ``what you think? You are a world beauty or what that I am dying to touch”. They would drop some famous actress’ name too.

One of my CPM friends confessed secretly to me that he is scared to send his grown up daughter alone for tuitions in the evenings. He says, chechi, times have changed. “Yes the times have changed and so have the people. Now where is the movement comrade?” I wanted to ask. Let me leave it at that and may be for another occasion.

So Jayaram is in no way different from these larger groups. It is yet another matter that Mr. Jayaram’s pleasantly-plum-relatively-on-the-darker-side-wife (who was also an actress), was considered to be one of the fattest in that era. One may still be interested to know whether Mr.Jayarm addresses her as a brown fat buffalo and refuses to look at her at home???

4 comments:

Jiby said...

After reading your post, and your question of "What happened to the movement" I wondered if we can draw a link between Unnithan's arrest, attack on Zachariah, the boycott of Sreelekha in Payyannur and Jayaram's controversies.

In a society were no healthy debates and movements for gender equality are not foistered even by the left progressive forces, its no surprise Jayaram, a comedy star blurted out these words because he is not exposed to anything beyond vulgar generalizations and stereotypes of people, glorification of certain physical attributes of men and women alike and the march of patriarchy.

Infact at our office, we were saying Jayaram if he had some amount of calibre should have asked the tv anchor if he had nothing better to ask him, but being the humble, joke-cracking star he responded with one of those dialogues that he would have got away with when said in a film in the guise of a character, but not in real life.

like you pointed out it was the failure of gender politics that tamil chauvinists had to raise this issue. how beautiful it would have been if instead it was women in both states who raised their voice against the star. a lost opportunity really, but in no way surprising because the number of feminists in public space have diminished in Kerala, its out and out a man's world here. and i confess at times even i regress to conservatism now, and often am not even aware of it.

Unknown said...

jayaram has all along been making chauvinixtic comments.not one of the self=respecting malayalis ever responded Shanta.I agree with you that "tamil" women suffer just like all other women but the fact remains that it was his jibe at Tamil women that has made him(or has it?)watch his words and laughs.and regarding the movement i wonder whether it was ever an antidote to sexism and chauvinism.things are so depressing sometimes here!

meghamalhar said...

Shanta, u remember one ex JNUite Malayali man's comment on Barbari masjid..........and my answer?

Erinjiyal Santha Kesavan said...

sorry Leela, I do remember the context but not the exact words..
please post it again for me and also for my blog friends